“God’s definition of a real man,” Donald Miller told 900 high school guys a few years ago, “is a person with a penis.”
That’s where he landed after spending years trying to figure out — not having grown up with a father — what it means to be a man.
He kept running into definitions that left him or others out. The Promise Keepers rally he attended (much of which he liked) sold bumper stickers saying “Real Men Love Jesus.” That was just typical, he thought, of views that leave some guys out. What’s the message we’re sending to young men in our society if they don’t (yet, perhaps) love Jesus? Are they not really men?
“The rally taught me what a man does, and how loud a man must cheer, but apart from shallow bumper-sticker logic, Promise Keepers didn’t define the term. I found myself looking for a general definition. Because, if I had a general definition of a man, I would know whether or not I was one.”
He went to a men’s group at his church, but that threw him into further despair. It sounded like being a real man meant liking war movies, NASCAR, and football analogies — which he didn’t. “I couldn’t sit through men’s meetings anymore without rolling my eyes, or, at the end of prayers, sarcastically replacing the common phrase Amen with a loud and guttural Git ‘er Dun.
Here’s the tragic part of all this:
“I spent a lot of time believing I wasn’t a man because I didn’t like football analogies, or because I didn’t want to put a cheesy bumper sticker on my car, or, well, because I didn’t have a father. In a way, the guys who are promoting this approach to manhood are pretty innocent. I realize they are just trying to keep guys from yelling at their wives. But when those tactics hit my insecurities, they created a twinge. Tell a guy who grew up without a father that he is not a man unless . . . and he will automatically assume he isn’t one. I didn’t need manipulation. I needed affirmation.”
So he kept exploring: What does it mean to be a man? And he came to that simple conclusion: A real man is a person with a penis. If you have a penis, he insists, God has spoken.
You don’t have to like certain movies, you don’t have to be from Mars (or Venus — whichever it is), you don’t have to go deer hunting, you don’t have to be able to overhaul a car (whew!), you don’t have to coach baseball.
Any time we tell people that REAL MEN are a certain way (they love Braveheart or they hate shopping or they love Jesus), we are creating an environment where young men — and some not so young men — are left questioning whether or not they really belong to the group.
So there it is: a real man is a person with a penis. That’s not all it takes to be a GOOD man, for sure. But for a young man searching for his identity, it was critical to realize that God has (in the biological evidence) spoken. Trust him. “If God has spoken, then I have within me whatever it takes to do the things a man needs to do, to become a good man for a woman, for some kids, for an office, for whatever it is God wants me to do.”
(Quotes taken from To Own a Dragon
.)
- - - -
Check out the writings of my buddy Grant Boone at www.pga.com. Move over, Rick Reilly!